Question.

Leica M2 or Mamiya 7?

—Peter.

18 thoughts on “Question.

  1. Ian says:

    Toss a coin it may depend on your preferred lenses, I have M3 and RZ67 trouble is they both have great lenses or go out of the box Rolleiflex 2.8f Zeiss lens like Henry. Not much help I know.

  2. beautifulgrain says:

    Both! 🙂 Knowing your “aperture wide open” style, had you considered Norita66 system with 80mm F2 lens? Rocking it now – lens is something special…

  3. Wait until one month before your next overseas vacation. That time in between will help clear your mind – in theory, anyway.

    Or, think of it like this: you’re out and about on a beautiful clear warm evening and everything is just painted with amazing light. What rolls of film are in your pocket, and into which camera are you loading them?

    Or, alternatively, examine completely irrational choices. E.g. ARRI 435, Panavision Millennium XL2, Braun Nizo S800.

  4. mewanchuk says:

    No-brainer for sure…M2.

    You tend to experiment more (and take photos which are more emotive) with a 35mm rangefinder body. While I do realize you are intoxicated with the medium format IQ, the trade-off in body size, lens choices, number of exposures, ease of development and scanning, and relative convenience just do not justify it. Pick the camera that will inspire you to produce, and the one you will likely have with you.

  5. Henry Beckmeyer says:

    Hmmm…M2 is a work of mechanical art with the possibility to use lenses with brilliant rendering. Mamiya is a plasticy thing with very sharp, but rather soulless lenses. It does, however, have all that film real estate to work with.

    I’d choose the M2 every time, though. Small and compact, very usable in low light, it’s a camera you could carry everywhere.

    • Hi Henry, though I agree with you that the M2 is a mechanical work of art and the Mamiya 7 is a plasticy thing, I’m not sure that I would call the Mamiya lenses soulless. I actually think that the biggest positive difference to my photography came when I started to use medium format film, specifically with the Mamiya 7 (and RZ67). Here are a few shots from the Mamiya 7 system:













  6. Andy Gemmell says:

    M2.

    I LOVE what the Mamiya 7 can bring to the party (lenses as good as Leica in my view) though I agree with Mark.

    Another left field suggestion, the Mamiya 6. I’d like to see you create some square format images, and what travel or walking you can do the camera comes in slightly smaller than Mamiya 7.

Leave a Reply to Ian Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s